IL License Number: 104.017181

The Hidden Dangers of Double Layering Shingles: Why It’s Not Worth the Risk

When it comes to maintaining your roof, there are many decisions to make, one of which is whether to double layer your shingles. At first glance, this might seem like a cost-effective solution—why not simply add a new layer of shingles over the old one? However, the reality is that double layering shingles can lead to significant problems down the road. Here, we’ll explore the key reasons why this practice is not advisable and why a complete tear-off is often the better choice.

1. Hidden Damage

One of the biggest drawbacks of double layering shingles is that it can conceal underlying damage. Over time, your roof may develop issues such as leaks, rot, or structural damage. Adding a new layer of shingles on top of the old ones makes it impossible to inspect and repair these hidden problems. This can lead to worsening damage that remains unnoticed until it becomes a major issue.
The roof underneath can be inspected if you have an attic. However, if you have a vaulted ceiling or no access underneath, this is when the double layer of shingles can be a real issue.
Hidden Roof Plywood Damage

2. Increased Weight

Roofs are designed to support a specific weight load, including the original layer of shingles and occasional snow or ice accumulation. Adding a second layer of shingles significantly increases the weight on your roof structure. This additional weight can stress the underlying materials, potentially leading to structural damage. In the worst-case scenario, it could cause your roof to sag or even collapse under extreme conditions.

3. Reduced Lifespan

Double layering shingles can also reduce the lifespan of your roof. The heat retention between the layers can cause the shingles to deteriorate more quickly. Additionally, the new layer won’t adhere as well to the old layer as it would to a clean, prepared surface. This can lead to curling, buckling, and premature failure of the shingles, necessitating another replacement sooner than expected.

4. Poor Aesthetics

A double-layered roof often looks uneven and unattractive. The new shingles may not lay flat due to the old layer’s texture and any existing warping or damage. 

This can detract from your home’s curb appeal and even affect its resale value. A single, properly installed layer of shingles will always look better and perform more effectively.
Double Layered Shingles

5. Compromised Ventilation

Proper roof ventilation is crucial for maintaining the health of your roofing system and your home. Double layering can disrupt airflow, leading to heat and moisture buildup in your attic. This can cause a range of problems, from increased energy costs due to poor insulation to mold and mildew growth, which can impact indoor air quality and your family’s health.

6. Higher Long-Term Costs

While double layering might seem like a cheaper option initially, it often leads to higher costs in the long run. The need for more frequent repairs, the potential for structural damage, and the reduced lifespan of your roof can add up to significant expenses over time. Investing in a complete tear-off and replacement ensures that your roof is properly inspected, repaired, and installed, providing better protection and peace of mind.

A Real-Life Holda Case Study: Hoffman Estates Homeowner

A homeowner in Hoffman Estates, Illinois, approached us with several roofing issues, including the need for a complete roof replacement, a significantly overheated attic indicating poor ventilation, damaged trim around the garage door, and a large algae spot. Upon inspection, we discovered the home had two layers of existing shingles, which added to the weight of the roof and trapped heat, exacerbating the ventilation problem.
To address these issues, we developed a comprehensive plan that included removing all existing shingles and replacing them with a single layer of GAF Timberline HDZ shingles. We also improved ventilation by adding ridge vents, soffit vents, and baffle channels, and replaced the damaged trim and removed the algae. The result was a durable, aesthetically pleasing roof that addressed all the homeowner’s concerns and prevented future problems. This case study underscores the importance of avoiding double layering and opting for a complete tear-off and replacement.

Conclusion: Invest in Quality

When it comes to your roof, cutting corners is never a good idea. Double layering shingles may save money upfront, but the hidden costs and potential risks far outweigh the benefits. At our roofing and siding business, we believe in doing things right the first time. That means performing a thorough inspection, addressing any underlying issues, and installing a new roof that will stand the test of time.

If you’re considering a roof replacement, don’t settle for a quick fix. Contact us today to schedule a consultation and learn more about why a complete tear-off and replacement is the best choice for your home. Investing in quality now will save you time, money, and headaches in the future.